Literacy in Composition Studies Feb 2021 RSS Open Access

Self-Contradiction in Faculty's Talk about Writing: Making and Unmaking Autonomous Models of Literacy

Andrea R. Olinger University of Louisville Hospital

Abstract

In Writing Across the Curriculum/Writing in the Disciplines and Academic Literacies, researchers have produced compelling evidence of the disjunction between faculty members’ assertions that good writing is universal—i.e., the autonomous model of literacy—and faculty’s own tacit practice of discipline-specific conventions. In studies of race and language in education, scholars have identified disconnections between what teachers profess to value—e.g., students’ right to their own language—and how they actually grade. Contradictions are a natural part of any ideology, and these are commonly understood to demonstrate the resilience of the autonomous model. In this article, however, I introduce a set of theoretical tools from the sociology of scientific knowledge—namely, the concept of interpretative repertoires and of variability in participants’ interpretations as an analytic resource—that can reveal cracks in the autonomous model. Although these tools are over thirty years old, they have not circulated widely in literacy and composition studies. I apply the tools to text-based interviews with two faculty writers who had espoused universal “rules” for writing. After identifying apparent disconnections between the rules and their own practices or those of other writers with whom they worked, I present this evidence to them and analyze their explanations: They maintain that the rules still apply, but their accounts are complex, shifting, and self-contradictory. These case studies reveal, rather than its strength, the inherent instability of the autonomous model. Ultimately, I hope that these research tools can, in conjunction with systemic efforts, aid in dismantling the construct of “good writing” and its inherent privileging of white language practices.

Journal
Literacy in Composition Studies
Published
2021-02-12
DOI
10.21623/1.8.2.2
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Gold
Topics
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation context

Cited by in this index (14)

  1. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  2. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  3. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  4. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  5. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
Show all 14 →
  1. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  2. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  3. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  4. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  5. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  6. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  7. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  8. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  9. Shah (2024)
    Teaching Dispositions: Cultivating Critical Hope in Community Literacy
    Literacy in Composition Studies

References (144) · 29 in this index

  1. Agha, Asif. Language and Social Relations. Cambridge UP, 2007.
     ↗
  2. Anson, Chris M. “Black Holes: Writing Across the Curriculum, Assessment, and the Gravitational Invisibility o…
  3. Anson (2016)
    The Pop Warner Chronicles: A Case Study in Contextual Adaptation and the Transf…
    College Composition and Communication
  4. Babel, Anna M., editor. Awareness and Control in Sociolinguistic Research. Cambridge UP, 2016.
     ↗
  5. Berkenkotter et al. (1983)
    Decisions and Revisions: The Planning Strategies of a Publishing Writer, and Re…
    College Composition and Communication
Show all 144 →
  1. Ayash (2016)
    Conditions of (Im)Possibility: Postmonolingual Language Representations in Acad…
    College English
  2. Boughey, Chrissie. “‘Naming’ Students’ Problems: An Analysis of Language-Related Discourses at a South Africa…
     ↗
  3. Calvet, Louis-Jean. Towards an Ecology of World Languages. Translated by Andrew Brown, Polity, 2006.
  4. Camps, Anna Mundó, and Marta Milian. “Metalinguistic Activity in Learning to Write: An Introduction.” Metalin…
     ↗
  5. Chabris, Christopher F., and Daniel J. Simons. The Invisible Gorilla: And Other Ways Our Intuitions Deceive U…
  6. Cox et al. (2018)
    Building Sustainable WAC Programs: A Whole Systems Approach
    The WAC Journal
  7. Donahue, Christiane. “Transfer, Portability, Generalization: (How) Does Composition Expertise ‘Carry’?” Explo…
     ↗
  8. Edley, Nigel. “Analysing Masculinity: Interpretative Repertoires, Ideological Dilemmas and Subject Positions.…
  9. Flash, Pamela. “From Apprised to Revised: Faculty in the Disciplines Change What They Never Knew They Knew.” …
     ↗
  10. Flores, Nelson. “From Academic Language to Language Architecture: Challenging Raciolinguistic Ideologies in R…
     ↗
  11. Flores, Nelson, and Jonathan Rosa. “Undoing Appropriateness: Raciolinguistic Ideologies and Language Diversit…
     ↗
  12. Gardner, Rod. When Listeners Talk: Response Tokens and Listener Stance. John Benjamins, 2001.
     ↗
  13. Geisler, Cheryl. Academic Literacy and the Nature of Expertise: Reading, Writing, and Knowing in Academic Phi…
  14. Gilbert, G. Nigel, and Michael Mulkay. Opening Pandora’s Box: A Sociological Analysis of Scientists’ Discours…
  15. Giltrow, Janet. “Meta-Genre.” The Rhetoric and Ideology of Genre: Strategies for Stability and Change, edited…
  16. Henkin, Joshua. “Why ‘Show, Don’t Tell’ is the Great Lie of Writing Workshops.” Writer’s Digest, www.writersd…
  17. Heritage, John. “A Change-of-State Token and Aspects of its Sequential Placement.” Structures of Social Actio…
     ↗
  18. Hyland, Ken. “Disciplinary Interactions: Metadiscourse in L2 Postgraduate Writing.” Journal of Second Languag…
     ↗
  19. Inoue, Asao B. Antiracist Writing Assessment Ecologies: Teaching and Assessing Writing for a Socially Just Fu…
     ↗
  20. Inoue (2019)
    Classroom Writing Assessment as an Antiracist Practice
    Pedagogy
  21. Inoue (2019)
    2019 CCCC Chair’s Address: How Do We Language So People Stop Killing Each Other…
    College Composition and Communication
  22. Kareem, Jamila M. “Sustained Communities for Sustained Learning: Connecting Culturally Sustaining Pedagogy to…
     ↗
  23. Kells, Michelle Hall. “Writing Across Communities: Deliberation and the Discursive Possibilities of WAC.” Ref…
  24. Lancaster (2016)
    Using Corpus Results to Guide the Discourse-Based Interview: A Case Study of a …
    Journal of Writing Research
  25. Lawes, Rachel. “Marriage: An Analysis of Discourse.” British Journal of Social Psychology, vol. 38, no. 1, 19…
     ↗
  26. Lea, Mary R., and Brian V. Street. “Student Writing in Higher Education: An Academic Literacies Approach.” St…
     ↗
  27. Lewis, Mark C. “A Critique of the Principle of Error Correction as a Theory of Social Change.”Language in Soc…
     ↗
  28. Lindenman et al. (2018)
    Revision and Reflection: A Study of (Dis)Connections between Writing Knowledge …
    College Composition and Communication
  29. McCloskey, Rose. “A Guide to Discourse Analysis.” Nurse Researcher, vol. 16, no. 1, 2008, pp. 24-44.
     ↗
  30. Nowacek, Rebecca S. Agents of Integration: Understanding Transfer as a Rhetorical Act. Southern Illinois UP, 2011.
  31. Odell, Lee, Dixie Goswami, and Anne Herrington. “The Discourse-Based Interview: A Procedure for Exploring Tac…
  32. Olinger (2014)
    On the Instability of Disciplinary Style: Common and Conflicting Metaphors and …
    Research in the Teaching of English
  33. Olinger (2016)
    A Sociocultural Approach to Style
    Rhetoric Review
  34. Olinger (2020)
    Visual Embodied Actions in Interview-Based Writing Research: A Methodological A…
    Written Communication
  35. Olson, David. “From Utterance to Text: The Bias of Language in Speech and Writing.” Harvard Educational Revie…
     ↗
  36. Perryman-Clark, Staci M., and Collin Lamont Craig. “Black Student Success Models: Institutional Profiles of W…
  37. Pinker, Steven. “Why Academics Stink at Writing.” The Chronicle of Higher Education, 26 Sept. 2014, www.chron…
  38. Poe (2013)
    Re-Framing Race in Teaching Writing Across the Curriculum
    Across the Disciplines
  39. Potter, Jonathan, and Alexa Hepburn. “Eight Challenges for Interview Researchers.” The SAGE Handbook of Inter…
     ↗
  40. Potter, Jonathan, and Michael J. Mulkay. “Scientists’ Interview Talk: Interviews as a Technique for Revealing…
  41. Preston, Dennis R. “Whaddayaknow?: The Modes of Folk Linguistic Awareness.” Language Awareness, vol. 5. no. 1…
     ↗
  42. Prior, Paul A. “Tracing Process: How Texts Come Into Being.” What Writing Does and How It Does It, edited by …
  43. ---. Writing/Disciplinarity: A Sociohistoric Account of Literate Activity in the Academy. Lawrence Erlbaum As…
  44. Rosa, Jonathan, and Nelson Flores. “Unsettling Race and Language: Toward a Raciolinguistic Perspective.” Lang…
     ↗
  45. Rose (1985)
    The Language of Exclusion: Writing Instruction at the University
    College English
  46. Sacks, Harvey, Emmanuel A. Schegloff, and Gail Jefferson. “A Simplest Systematics for the Organization of Tur…
     ↗
  47. Schimel, Joshua. Writing Science: How to Write Papers That Get Cited and Proposals That Get Funded. Oxford UP…
  48. Silverstein, Michael. “The Limits of Awareness.” Sociolinguistic Working Paper No. 84.
  49. Southwest Educational Development Laboratory. Reprinted in Linguistic Anthropology: A Reader, edited by Aless…
  50. Simons, Daniel J. “The Demographics of Surveys: Phone vs. Mechanical Turk.” 2012, blog.dansimons.com/2012/12/…
  51. ---. “Writing and Revising.” Website, www.dansimons.com/resources/writing_tips.html. Accessed 3 December 2020.
  52. Sprat, Thomas. The History of the Royal Society (Selections), edited by Jack Lynch, www.jacklynch.net/Texts/s…
  53. Starke-Meyerring, Doreen. “The Paradox of Writing in Doctoral Education: Student Experiences.” Doctoral Educa…
     ↗
  54. Street, Brian V. Literacy in Theory and Practice. Cambridge UP, 1984.
  55. Sword, Helen. Stylish Academic Writing. Harvard UP, 2012.
     ↗
  56. Talja, Sanna. “Analyzing Qualitative Interview Data: The Discourse Analytic Method.” Library & Information Sc…
     ↗
  57. Thaiss, Christopher, and Terry Myers Zawacki. Engaged Writers, Dynamic Disciplines: Research on the Academic …
  58. Tileagă, Cristian, and Elizabeth Stokoe. “Introduction: The Evolution of Discursive Psychology: From Classic …
     ↗
  59. Verschueren, Jef. Ideology in Language Use: Pragmatic Guidelines for Empirical Research. Cambridge UP, 2012.
     ↗
  60. Walters (1993)
    Scientific Method and Prose Style in the Early Royal Society
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  61. Wetherell, Margaret, and Jonathan Potter. “Discourse Analysis and the Identification of Interpretative Repert…
  62. Wiggins, Sally. Discursive Psychology: Theory, Method and Applications. SAGE, 2017.
     ↗
  63. Wilder, Laura. Rhetorical Strategies and Genre Conventions in Literary Studies: Teaching and Writing in the D…
  64. Wilkinson, Sue, and Celia Kitzinger. “Surprise As an Interactional Achievement: Reaction Tokens in Conversati…
     ↗
  65. Williams-Farrier (2017)
    “Talkin’ bout Good & Bad” Pedagogies: Code-Switching vs. Comparative Rhetorical…
    College Composition and Communication
  66. Wingate, Ursula. “Approaches to Academic Literacy Instruction: Classifications, Conflicts and New Directions.…
  67. Young, Vershawn Ashanti. “‘Nah, We Straight’: An Argument Against Code Switching.” JAC: Journal of Advanced C…
  68. Agha, Asif.Language and Social Relations.Cambridge UP, 2007.
     ↗
  69. Anson, Chris M. “Black Holes: Writing Across the Curriculum, Assessment, and the Gravitational Invisibility …
     ↗
  70. ---. “The Pop Warner Chronicles: A Case Study in Contextual Adaptation and the Transfer of Writ…
     ↗
  71. Babel, Anna M., editor.Awareness and Control in Sociolinguistic Research. Cambridge UP, 2016.
     ↗
  72. Berkenkotter et al. (1983)
    Decisions and Revisions: The Planning Strategies of a Publishing Writer, and Re…
    College Composition and Communication
  73. Bou Ayash, Nancy. “Conditions of (Im)Possibility: Postmonolingual Language Representations in A…
     ↗
  74. Boughey, Chrissie. “‘Naming’ Students’ Problems: An Analysis of Language-Related Discourses at a…
     ↗
  75. Calvet, Louis-Jean.Towards an Ecology of World Languages. Translated by Andrew Brown, Polity, 2006.
     ↗
  76. Camps, Anna Mundó, and Marta Milian. “Metalinguistic Activity in Learning to Write: An Introduct…
     ↗
  77. Chabris, Christopher F., and Daniel J. Simons.The Invisible Gorilla:And Other Ways Our Intuitions Deceive Us…
     ↗
  78. Cox, Michelle, Jeffrey R. Galin, and Dan Melzer.Sustainable WAC: A Whole Systems Approach to Launching and …
     ↗
  79. Donahue, Christiane. “Transfer, Portability, Generalization: (How) Does Composition Expertise ‘Carry’?”Explo…
     ↗
  80. Edley, Nigel. “Analysing Masculinity: Interpretative Repertoires, Ideological Dilemmas and Subje…
     ↗
  81. Flash, Pamela. “From Apprised to Revised: Faculty in the Disciplines Change What They Never Knew They Knew.”…
     ↗
  82. Flores, Nelson. “From Academic Language to Language Architecture: Challenging Raciolinguistic I…
     ↗
  83. Flores, Nelson, and Jonathan Rosa. “Undoing Appropriateness: Raciolinguistic Ideologies and Lang…
     ↗
  84. Gardner, Rod.When Listeners Talk: Response Tokens and Listener Stance.John Benjamins, 2001.
     ↗
  85. Geisler, Cheryl.Academic Literacy and the Nature of Expertise: Reading, Writing, and Knowing in Academic Phi…
     ↗
  86. Gilbert, G. Nigel, and Michael Mulkay.Opening Pandora’s Box: A Sociological Analysis of Scientists’ Discours…
     ↗
  87. Giltrow, Janet. “Meta-Genre.”The Rhetoric and Ideology of Genre: Strategies for Stability andChange, edited…
     ↗
  88. Henkin, Joshua. “Why ‘Show, Don’t Tell’ is the Great Lie of Writing Workshops.”Writer’s Digest,www.writersd…
     ↗
  89. Heritage, John. “A Change-of-State Token and Aspects of its Sequential Placement.”Structures of Social Acti…
     ↗
  90. Pennington (2010)
    Postgraduate Writing
    Writing and Pedagogy
  91. Inoue, Asao B.Antiracist Writing Assessment Ecologies: Teaching and Assessing Writing for a Socially Just Fu…
     ↗
  92. Inoue (2019)
    Classroom Writing Assessment as an Antiracist Practice
    Pedagogy
  93. Inoue (2019)
    2019 CCCC Chair’s Address: How Do We Language So People Stop Killing Each Other…
    College Composition and Communication
  94. Kareem, Jamila M. “Sustained Communities for Sustained Learning: Connecting Culturally Sustaining Pedagogy …
     ↗
  95. Kells, Michelle Hall. “Writing Across Communities: Deliberation and the Discursive Possibilities…
     ↗
  96. Lancaster, Zak. “Using Corpus Results to Guide the Discourse-Based Interview: A Study of One Student’s Aware…
     ↗
  97. Lawes, Rachel. “Marriage: An Analysis of Discourse.”British Journal of Social Psychology, vol. 38…
     ↗
  98. Lea, Mary R., and Brian V. Street. “Student Writing in Higher Education: An Academic Literacies …
     ↗
  99. Lewis, Mark C. “A Critique of the Principle of Error Correction as a Theory of Social Change.”Language in So…
     ↗
  100. Lindenman et al. (2018)
    Revision and Reflection: A Study of (Dis)Connections between Writing Knowledge …
    College Composition and Communication
  101. McCloskey, Rose. “A Guide to Discourse Analysis.”Nurse Researcher, vol. 16, no. 1, 2008, pp. 24-44.
     ↗
  102. Nowacek, Rebecca S.Agents of Integration: Understanding Transfer as a Rhetorical Act.Southern Illinois UP, 2011.
     ↗
  103. Odell, Lee, Dixie Goswami, and Anne Herrington. “The Discourse-Based Interview: A Procedure for …
     ↗
  104. Olinger (2014)
    On the Instability of Disciplinary Style: Common and Conflicting Metaphors and …
    Research in the Teaching of English
  105. Olinger (2016)
    A Sociocultural Approach to Style
    Rhetoric Review
  106. Olinger (2020)
    Visual Embodied Actions in Interview-Based Writing Research: A Methodological A…
    Written Communication
  107. Olson, David. “From Utterance to Text: The Bias of Language in Speech and Writing.”HarvardEducational Review…
     ↗
  108. Perryman-Clark, Staci M., and Collin Lamont Craig. “Black Student Success Models: Institutional Profiles of …
     ↗
  109. Pinker, Steven. “Why Academics Stink at Writing.”The Chronicle of Higher Education, 26 Sept. 2014, www.chr…
     ↗
  110. Poe (2013)
    Re-Framing Race in Teaching Writing Across the Curriculum
    Across the Disciplines
  111. Potter, Jonathan, and Alexa Hepburn. “Eight Challenges for Interview Researchers.”The SAGE Handbook of Inte…
     ↗
  112. Potter, Jonathan, and Michael J. Mulkay. “Scientists’ Interview Talk: Interviews as a Technique for Revealin…
     ↗
  113. Preston, Dennis R. “Whaddayaknow?: The Modes of Folk Linguistic Awareness.”Language Awareness, vol. 5. no. …
     ↗
  114. Prior, Paul A. “Tracing Process: How Texts Come Into Being.”What Writing Does and How It Does It, edited by…
     ↗
  115. ---.Writing/Disciplinarity: A Sociohistoric Account of Literate Activity in the Academy.Lawrence Erlbaum As…
     ↗
  116. Rosa, Jonathan, and Nelson Flores. “Unsettling Race and Language: Toward a Raciolinguistic Perspective.”Lan…
     ↗
  117. Rose (1985)
    The Language of Exclusion: Writing Instruction at the University
    College English
  118. Sacks, Harvey, Emmanuel A. Schegloff, and Gail Jefferson. “A Simplest Systematics for the Organization of Tu…
     ↗
  119. Schimel, Joshua.Writing Science: How to Write Papers That Get Cited and Proposals That Get Funded.Oxford UP, 2012.
     ↗
  120. Molloy et al. (2022)
    Neurotic Loops and the Limits of Awareness: Toward New Apertures for Activist-O…
    Rhetoric of Health and Medicine
  121. Southwest Educational Development Laboratory. Reprinted inLinguistic Anthropology: AReader, edited by Alessa…
     ↗
  122. Simons, Daniel J. “The Demographics of Surveys: Phone vs. Mechanical Turk.” 2012, blog.dansimons.com/2012/12…
     ↗
  123. Herndl et al. (2003)
    Writing and Revising the Disciplines
    College Composition and Communication
  124. Sprat, Thomas.The History of the Royal Society (Selections), edited by Jack Lynch, www.jacklynch…
     ↗
  125. Starke-Meyerring, Doreen. “The Paradox of Writing in Doctoral Education: Student Experiences.”Do…
     ↗
  126. Street, Brian V.Literacy in Theory and Practice.Cambridge UP, 1984.
     ↗
  127. Sword, Helen.Stylish Academic Writing.Harvard UP, 2012.
     ↗
  128. Talja, Sanna. “Analyzing Qualitative Interview Data: The Discourse Analytic Method.”Library& Information Sci…
     ↗
  129. Thaiss, Christopher, and Terry Myers Zawacki.Engaged Writers, Dynamic Disciplines: Research on the Academic …
     ↗
  130. Tileagă, Cristian, and Elizabeth Stokoe. “Introduction: The Evolution of Discursive Psychology: From Classic…
     ↗
  131. Verschueren, Jef.Ideology in Language Use: Pragmatic Guidelines for Empirical Research.Cambridge UP, 2012.
     ↗
  132. Walters (1993)
    Scientific Method and Prose Style in the Early Royal Society
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  133. Wetherell, Margaret, and Jonathan Potter. “Discourse Analysis and the Identification of Interpre…
     ↗
  134. Wiggins, Sally.Discursive Psychology: Theory, Method and Applications.SAGE, 2017.
     ↗
  135. Wilder, Laura.Rhetorical Strategies and Genre Conventions in Literary Studies: Teaching and Writing in the D…
     ↗
  136. Wilkinson, Sue, and Celia Kitzinger. “Surprise As an Interactional Achievement: Reaction Tokens …
     ↗
  137. Williams-Farrier, Bonnie J. “‘Talkin’ bout Good & Bad’ Pedagogies: Code-Switching vs. Comparativ…
     ↗
  138. Wingate, Ursula. “Approaches to Academic Literacy Instruction: Classifications, Conflicts and New Directions…
     ↗
  139. Ashanti (2009)
    'Nah, we straight': An argument against code switching
    JAC: A Journal of Rhetoric, Culture, and Politics
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related articles

  1. Writing and Pedagogy Jun 2026
    Writing Across the “French Immersion” Curriculum: An Instructional Model for Writing Instruction ↗
    Renée Bourgoin; Josée Le Bouthillier
    writing pedagogy writing across the curriculum multilingual writers literacy studies
  2. Pedagogy Oct 2025
    Contributors ↗
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory cultural rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy advanced composition creative writing writing across the curriculum graduate education two-year college service learning teacher development technical communication professional writing labor and working conditions archival research multimodality artificial intelligence literacy studies race and writing gender and writing disability studies literary studies editorial matter
  3. Journal of Academic Writing Sep 2025
    Booksprints as a Learning Format for Students in Higher Education ↗
    Anja Voigt-Färber
    writing across the curriculum graduate education teacher development digital rhetoric literacy studies
  4. College Composition and Communication Sep 2025
    From an Unsettled Middle: A Critical-Ethical Stance for GenAI-Engaged Writing Assignments ↗
    Christopher Basgier; Lydia Wilkes
    first-year composition writing pedagogy writing across the curriculum argument writing centers artificial intelligence literacy studies
  5. Literacy in Composition Studies May 2025
    "Kids Don't Come with Instruction Manuals": A Mother Writing to Learn Across Her Lifespan ↗
    Anna D'Orazio
    rhetorical criticism writing across the curriculum literacy studies