Abstract

Failure is a significant issue for researchers conducting community-engaged work. This article responds to calls to share research failures more transparently and to create reflective spaces for students to examine moments of failure. We offer our experience adapting three problem-solving strategies from a community literacy course (adaptive problem-solving, rivaling, and critical incident interviewing) to help each other revisit our own “failed” attempts at community-engaged work. By applying these problem-solving strategies to reflect on our experiences—advocating for graduate student parents, working with a summer literacy program, and collaborating with parents of disabled children—we show how these strategies can transform an initial sense of stigmatized failure into a longer process of inquiry and growth. Our approach, we believe, represents an important literate practice for community-based scholars, not only for those seeking to create more collaborative reflective space within university-community partnership, but also for novice scholars navigating the challenges of community-engaged work for the first time.

Journal
Literacy in Composition Studies
Published
2022-11-15
DOI
10.21623/1.10.1.5
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Gold
Topics
Export

Citation context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (209) · 174 in this index

  1. Ackerman, John, and David J. Coogan, editors. The Public Work of Rhetoric: Citizen-Scholars and Civic Engagem…
  2. Community Literacy Journal
  3. College Composition and Communication
  4. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  5. College Composition and Communication
Show all 209 →
  1. Community Literacy Journal
  2. Rhetoric Review
  3. College English
  4. Community Literacy Journal
  5. Community Literacy Journal
  6. Community Literacy Journal
  7. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  8. Community Literacy Journal
  9. Community Literacy Journal
  10. Community Literacy Journal
  11. College Composition and Communication
  12. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  13. College Composition and Communication
  14. Community Literacy Journal
  15. Rhetoric Review
  16. College English
  17. Community Literacy Journal
  18. Community Literacy Journal
  19. Community Literacy Journal
  20. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  21. Community Literacy Journal
  22. Community Literacy Journal
  23. Community Literacy Journal
  24. College Composition and Communication
  25. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  26. College Composition and Communication
  27. Community Literacy Journal
  28. Rhetoric Review
  29. College English
  30. Community Literacy Journal
  31. Community Literacy Journal
  32. Community Literacy Journal
  33. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  34. Community Literacy Journal
  35. Community Literacy Journal
  36. Community Literacy Journal
  37. College Composition and Communication
  38. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  39. College Composition and Communication
  40. Community Literacy Journal
  41. Rhetoric Review
  42. College English
  43. Community Literacy Journal
  44. Community Literacy Journal
  45. Community Literacy Journal
  46. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  47. Community Literacy Journal
  48. Community Literacy Journal
  49. Community Literacy Journal
  50. College Composition and Communication
  51. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  52. College Composition and Communication
  53. Community Literacy Journal
  54. Rhetoric Review
  55. College English
  56. Community Literacy Journal
  57. Community Literacy Journal
  58. Community Literacy Journal
  59. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  60. Community Literacy Journal
  61. Community Literacy Journal
  62. Community Literacy Journal
  63. College Composition and Communication
  64. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  65. College Composition and Communication
  66. Community Literacy Journal
  67. Rhetoric Review
  68. College English
  69. Community Literacy Journal
  70. Community Literacy Journal
  71. Community Literacy Journal
  72. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  73. Community Literacy Journal
  74. Community Literacy Journal
  75. Community Literacy Journal
  76. College Composition and Communication
  77. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  78. College Composition and Communication
  79. Community Literacy Journal
  80. Rhetoric Review
  81. College English
  82. Community Literacy Journal
  83. Community Literacy Journal
  84. Community Literacy Journal
  85. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  86. Community Literacy Journal
  87. Community Literacy Journal
  88. Community Literacy Journal
  89. College Composition and Communication
  90. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  91. College Composition and Communication
  92. Community Literacy Journal
  93. Rhetoric Review
  94. College English
  95. Community Literacy Journal
  96. Community Literacy Journal
  97. Community Literacy Journal
  98. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  99. Community Literacy Journal
  100. Community Literacy Journal
  101. Community Literacy Journal
  102. College Composition and Communication
  103. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  104. College Composition and Communication
  105. Community Literacy Journal
  106. Rhetoric Review
  107. College English
  108. Community Literacy Journal
  109. Community Literacy Journal
  110. Community Literacy Journal
  111. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  112. Community Literacy Journal
  113. Community Literacy Journal
  114. Community Literacy Journal
  115. College Composition and Communication
  116. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  117. College Composition and Communication
  118. Community Literacy Journal
  119. Rhetoric Review
  120. College English
  121. Community Literacy Journal
  122. Community Literacy Journal
  123. Community Literacy Journal
  124. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  125. Community Literacy Journal
  126. Community Literacy Journal
  127. Community Literacy Journal
  128. College Composition and Communication
  129. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  130. College Composition and Communication
  131. Community Literacy Journal
  132. Rhetoric Review
  133. College English
  134. Community Literacy Journal
  135. Community Literacy Journal
  136. Community Literacy Journal
  137. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  138. Community Literacy Journal
  139. Community Literacy Journal
  140. Community Literacy Journal
  141. College Composition and Communication
  142. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  143. College Composition and Communication
  144. Community Literacy Journal
  145. Rhetoric Review
  146. College English
  147. Community Literacy Journal
  148. Community Literacy Journal
  149. Community Literacy Journal
  150. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  151. Community Literacy Journal
  152. Community Literacy Journal
  153. Community Literacy Journal
  154. College Composition and Communication
  155. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  156. College Composition and Communication
  157. Community Literacy Journal
  158. Rhetoric Review
  159. College English
  160. Community Literacy Journal
  161. Community Literacy Journal
  162. Community Literacy Journal
  163. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  164. Community Literacy Journal
  165. Community Literacy Journal
  166. Ackerman, John, and David J. Coogan, editors.The Public Work of Rhetoric: Citizen-Scholars and Civic Engageme…
     ↗
  167. Community Literacy Journal
  168. Chell, Elizabeth. “Critical Incident Technique.”Essential Guide to Qualitative Methods in Organizational Rese…
     ↗
  169. Commer, Carolyn. “The Case of the Failed Childcare Center.” 2020. Personal Narrative.
     ↗
  170. College Composition and Communication
  171. Coogan, David J., and John Ackerman. “Introduction: The Space to Work in Public Life.” In Ackerman and Coogan…
     ↗
  172. College Composition and Communication
  173. Cushman, Ellen, and Erik Green. “Knowledge Work with the Cherokee Nation.” In Ackerman and Coogan, pp. 175–92.
     ↗
  174. Deans, Thomas.Writing Partnerships: Service-Learning in Composition. National Council of Teachers of English, 2000.
     ↗
  175. Edmondson, Amy. “Strategies for Learning from Failure.”Harvard Business Review, Apr. 2011,https://hbr.org/201…
     ↗
  176. Feigenbaum, Paul. “Telling Students It’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them It Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Fail…
     ↗
  177. Flanagan, John. “The Critical Incident Technique.”Psychological Bulletin, vol. 51, no. 4, 1954, pp. 327–58.
     ↗
  178. Flower, Linda.Community Literacy and the Rhetoric of Public Engagement. Southern Illinois UP, 2008.
     ↗
  179. College Composition and Communication
  180. Reflections: A Journal of Community-Engaged Writing and Rhetoric
  181. Flower, Linda, Elenore Long, and Lorraine Higgins.Learning to Rival: A Literate Practice for Intercultural In…
     ↗
  182. College English
  183. Community Literacy Journal
  184. Glavan, Mary. “The Case of the Failed Dissertation Interviews.”2020. Personal Narrative.
     ↗
  185. Rhetoric Review
  186. College English
  187. Grabill, Jeffrey T. “On Being Useful.” In Ackerman and Coogan, pp. 193–208.
     ↗
  188. Heifetz, Ronald A.Leadership Without Easy Answers. Belknap Press of Harvard UP, 1994.
     ↗
  189. Community Literacy Journal
  190. Hill, Lisa L. “Empowerment.”Keywords in Composition Studies, edited by Paul Heilker and Peter Vandenberg, Hei…
     ↗
  191. Community Literacy Journal
  192. Long, Elenore.A Responsive Rhetorical Art: Artistic Methods for Contemporary Public Life. 1st ed., U of Pitts…
     ↗
  193. Mathieu, Paula.Tactics of Hope: The Public Turn in English Composition. Heinemann, 2005.
     ↗
  194. College Composition and Communication
  195. Community Literacy Journal
  196. McLaughlin, Kenneth.Empowerment: A Critique. Routledge, 2016. Routledge Key Themes in Health and Society.
     ↗
  197. Mezirow, Jack.Transformative Dimensions of Adult Learning. 1st ed., Jossey-Bass, 1991. Higher and Adult Education.
     ↗
  198. Parks, Sharon Daloz.Leadership Can Be Taught: A Bold Approach for a Complex World. Harvard Business School P, 2005.
     ↗
  199. College English
  200. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  201. Community Literacy Journal
  202. Community Literacy Journal
  203. College Composition and Communication
  204. ---. “The Case of Conflicting Stakeholders.” 2020. Personal Narrative.
     ↗