Reflections: A Journal of Community-Engaged Writing and Rhetoric Sep 2020 Open Access

Rhetorics of Motherhood, Agency, and Reproductive Injustice in Healthcare Providers’ Narratives

Brianna R. Cusanno University of South Florida ; Niv Ketheeswaran University of South Florida

Abstract

Discriminatory policy structures related to segregation, criminalization, environmental regulation, and loan financing intersect to create severe racial inequities in reproductive health. These structures, and their material consequences for human lives, are constituted and perpetuated through discourse. Dominant narratives (DNs) provide stories that naturalize inequalities and are repeated until they become “common sense” by cultural members. The Reproductive Justice Movement (RJM) was founded by women of color activists and scholars to change oppressive structures and to promote the reproductive and human rights of all people. RJM activists have used personal stories as a resistive tool, recognizing that resistive stories can destabilize the taken-for-granted nature of DNs and the violent structures they uphold. In this article, we perform a Critical Narrative Analysis of three personal stories shared by reproductive healthcare providers to understand how their stories can perpetuate and/or resist oppressive DNs through their construction of marginalized patients as characters. We found that, in constructing narratives of patients, participants relied on three main DNs: Western Modernity, White Supremacy, and Neoliberalism. Drawing on these DNs, providers characterize patients as: Good or Bad (M)others, Victims, and Adversaries. Our goal is to show that narratives created with providers are political texts that constitute understandings of patients’ reproductive lives. We conclude with a re-telling of one narrative to emphasize the goals of reproductive justice and highlight the importance of re-framing the inequitable present in order to imagine equitable futures.

Journal
Reflections: A Journal of Community-Engaged Writing and Rhetoric
Published
2020-09-01
DOI
10.59236/rjv20i2pp219-244
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Gold
Topics
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (66)

  1. Adams (2016)
    Rhetorics of Unwed Motherhood and Shame
    Women's Studies in Communication  ↗
  2. (2015)
    Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Obstetrics and Gynecology
    Obstetrics & Gynecology  ↗
  3. Anderson (2017)
    The trauma of birth
    Health Care for Women International  ↗
  4. Banerjee (1988)
    Political economy of western medicine in third world countries
    The Great Concern
  5. Bloom (2003)
    The Colonization of (M)Others in Welfare-to-Work Education
    Educational Policy  ↗
Show all 66 →
  1. Bonds (2016)
    Beyond White privilege: Geographies of White supremacy and settler colonialism
    Progress in Human Geography  ↗
  2. Bridges (2011)
    Reproducing Race: An Ethnography of Pregnancy as a Site of Racialization
  3. Broadfoot (2007)
    Diverse Voices and Alternative Rationalities: Imagining Forms of Postcolonial Organizatio…
    Management Communication Quarterly  ↗
  4. Buchanan (2013)
    Rhetorics of Motherhood
  5. Burgess (2019)
    Healthcare Providers' Responses to Narrative Communication About Racial Healthcare Disparities
    Health Communication  ↗
  6. Charon (2012)
    At the Membranes of Care: Stories in Narrative Medicine
  7. Chin (2009)
    The other side of paradise: A memoir
  8. Collier (2019)
    Why Telling Our Own Story Is So Powerful for Black Americans
    Greater Good Magazine
  9. Cusanno (2019)
    It's a broken system that's designed to destroy': A critical narrative analysis of health…
  10. Cushing (2007)
    Optimizing medicines management: From compliance to concordance
    Therapeutics and Clinical Risk Management
  11. Delgado (1989)
    Storytelling for Oppositionists and Others: A Plea for Narrative
    Michigan Law Review  ↗
  12. Dussel (2006)
    Globalization, Organization and the Ethics of Liberation
    Organization  ↗
  13. Dutta (2014)
    A Culture-Centered Approach to Listening: Voices of Social Change
    International Journal of Listening  ↗
  14. Dutta (2014)
    Family Planning
  15. Dutta (2008)
    Theoretical foundations: Interpretive, critical, and cultural approaches to health commun…
  16. Ehrenreich (1993)
    The Colonization of the Womb
    Duke Law Journal  ↗
  17. Ellingson (2012)
    The SAGE handbook of interview research: The complexity of the craft
  18. Farmer (2004)
    Pathologies of Power: Health, Human Rights, and the New War on the Poor
  19. Together (2019)
    Forward Together
  20. Gilman (2014)
    The return of the welfare queen
    American University Journal of Gender Social Policy & Law
  21. Hansen (2017)
    New Medicine for the U.S. Health Care System: Training Physicians for Structural Interventions
    Academic Medicine: Journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges  ↗
  22. Harris (2019)
    Desert bloom: My wedding day, inside a California prison
  23. Harter (2014)
    Narrative Medicine
    Encyclopedia of Health Communication
  24. Harter (2005)
    Vital Problematics of Narrative Theorizing About Health and Healing
  25. Hartman (1997)
    Scenes of subjection: Terror, slavery, and self-making in 19th century America
  26. Hedge (1998)
    A View from Elsewhere: Locating Difference and the Politics of Representation from a Tran…
    Communication Theory  ↗
  27. Kostov (2018)
    I did try and point out about his dignity': A qualitative narrative study of patients and…
    BMJ Open  ↗
  28. Lindlof (2019)
    Qualitative communication research methods
  29. Mann (2013)
    Regulating Latina Youth Sexualities through Community Health Centers: Discourses and Prac…
    Gender & Society  ↗
  30. Martínez (2014)
    A Plea for Critical Race Theory Counterstory: Stock Story versus Counterstory Dialogues C…
    Composition Studies
  31. Mishler (1995)
    Dominant and contesting narratives in medical students' longitudinal audio diaries
    Journal of Narrative and Life History
  32. Monrouxe (2017)
    Hero, voyeur, judge: Understanding medical students' moral identities through professiona…
     ↗
  33. Morgensen (2010)
    Settler Homonationalism: Theorizing Settler Colonialism within Queer Modernities
    GLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies  ↗
  34. Mullan (2006)
    Narrative matters: The power of the personal essay in health policy
     ↗
  35. Nayak (2009)
    American Orientalism and American Exceptionalism: A Critical Rethinking of US Hegemony
    International Studies Review  ↗
  36. Omi (2015)
    Racial formation in the United States
  37. Owen (2013)
    Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities in Reproductive Medicine: An Evidence-Based Overview
    Seminars in Reproductive Medicine  ↗
  38. Polletta (2008)
    Storytelling in Politics
    Contexts  ↗
  39. Polletta (2008)
    Storytelling in social movements
  40. Rance (2017)
    Why Am I the Way I Am?' Narrative Work in the Context of Stigmatized Identities
    Qualitative Health Research  ↗
  41. Razack (2007)
    Stealing the Pain of Others: Reflections on Canadian Humanitarian Responses
    Review of Education, Reflections
  42. Riessman (2005)
    Narrative Analysis
  43. Riley (2004)
    Researching practice: The methodological case for narrative inquiry
    Health Education Research  ↗
  44. Roberts (1991)
    Punishing Drug Addicts Who Have Babies: Women of Color, Equality, and the Right of Privacy
    Harvard Law Review  ↗
  45. Roberts (1992)
    Racism and Patriarchy in the Meaning of Motherhood
    American University Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law
  46. Roberts (1996)
    Reconstructing the Patient: Starting with Women of Color
     ↗
  47. Roberts (2012)
    Prison, Foster Care, and the Systemic Punishment of Black Mothers
    UCLA Law Review
  48. Roberts (2017)
    Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the meaning of liberty
  49. Ross (2017)
    Conceptualizing reproductive justice theory: A manifesto for activism
  50. Ross (2017)
    Introduction
  51. Sastry (2014)
    Postcolonial studies of health
  52. Sharf (2011)
    Narrative turns epic: Continuing developments in health narrative scholarship
  53. Smith (2006)
    Heteropatriarchy and the three pillars of White supremacy: Rethinking women of color organizing
  54. Smith (2010)
    Female Voice and Feminist Text: Testimonio as a Form of Resistance in Latin America
    Florida Atlantic Comparative Studies Journal
  55. Souto-Manning (2014)
    Critical narrative analysis: The interplay of critical discourse and narrative analyses
    International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education  ↗
  56. Stapleton (2017)
    Telling the story: Meaning making in a community narrative
    Journal of Pragmatics  ↗
  57. Ten Have (2016)
    Global Bioethics: An introduction
     ↗
  58. Tracy (2009)
    Discourse Analysis: The Practice and Practical Value of Taping, Transcribing, and Analyzi…
  59. Tracy (2012)
    The Toxic and Mythical Combination of a Deductive Writing Logic for Inductive Qualitative…
    Departures in Critical Qualitative Research
  60. Whipps (2014)
    A Pragmatist Reading of Mary Parker Follett's Integrative Process
    Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society  ↗
  61. Woodiwiss (2017)
    Challenges for Feminist Research: Contested Stories, Dominant Narratives and Narrative Fr…
     ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related articles

  1. Argumentation Jun 2026
    Argumentation and Language in Identity Construction: A Discourse-Historical Analysis of Polarisation in the 2024 Trump-Harris Debate ↗
    Mitchell Thomas Welle; Nina Shtok
    discourse analysis argument race and writing public rhetoric
  2. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly May 2026
    Communicating Diversity and Inclusion in LinkedIn Job Advertisements ↗
    Rashid Ashraf; Said Badreddine; Mohamed I. Albeshr; Hamsa Al Ammari; Malik Muhammad Sheheryar Khan; Pranav Naithani
    discourse analysis professional writing race and writing
  3. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly Mar 2026
    An Analysis of Online Perceptions in Response to Microsoft’s and Google’s Sexual Harassment Scandals ↗
    Roxana D. Maiorescu
    discourse analysis social media race and writing editorial matter
  4. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly Sep 2025
    The Interrelation of Politeness, Culture, and Speech Acts in Multilingual Corporate Communication ↗
    Ena Belamaric
    discourse analysis teacher development professional writing multilingual writers second language acquisition race and writing
  5. The Peer Review Sep 2025
    The Writing Center as a Rebel Space: Stories of Tutoring and Writing with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder ↗
    Ghada Seifeddine
    discourse analysis teacher development writing centers peer tutoring empirical research multimodality literacy studies race and writing disability studies editorial matter