Written Communication Jan 2023

Humanistic Knowledge-Making and the Rhetoric of Literary Criticism: Special Topoi Meet Rhetorical Action

Sarah Banting Mount Royal University

Abstract

This article examines the power of special topoi to characterize the discourse of literary criticism, and through emphasis on rhetorical action, it sheds light on the limitations of topos analysis for characterizing research articles in disciplinary discourse more generally. Using an analytical approach drawn both from studies of topoi in disciplinary discourse and rhetorical genre theory, I examine a representative corpus of 21st-century literary research articles. I find that while most of the special topoi recognized by Fahnestock and Secor and Wilder remain prevalent in recent criticism, contemporary literary critics tend to draw on only a select subset of those topoi when making claims about their rhetorical actions. The topoi they use most often— mistaken-critic and paradigm—help identify the ways knowledge-making work is undertaken in literary criticism, a discipline often considered epideictic rather than epistemic. But what the special topoi do not capture is precisely the distinctly motivated, actively epistemic character of this disciplinary rhetoric. Based on these findings, I suggest that special topoi must be seen as functioning in the context of the rhetorical action undertaken by literary research articles. These articles undertake not simply persuasion but the particularly humanistic act I refer to as contributing to scholarly understanding: a rhetorical action worth attending to for scholars of disciplinary discourse, because it is deliberately more concerned with practice than product.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
2023-01-01
DOI
10.1177/07410883221133290
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation context

Cited by in this index (1)

  1. Li (2025)
    Beyond Surfaces and Depths: An SFL Analysis of Fine Gradations of Meaning in Un…
    Written Communication

References (58) · 8 in this index

  1. Bakhtin M. M. (1986)
    Speech genres and other late essays
  2. Balocco A. E. (2000)
    The ESPecialist
  3. Bammer A. (2018)
    PMLA
  4. 10.1353/esc.2016.0019
     ↗
  5. 10.1086/678694
     ↗
Show all 58 →
  1. 10.2307/j.ctt46nxp6
     ↗
  2. 10.7330/9781607324430.c002
     ↗
  3. Bawarshi A. S. (2010)
    Genre: An introduction to history, theory, research, and pedagogy
  4. Bazerman C. (2019)
    Landmark essays on rhetorical genre studies
  5. Bazerman C. (2000)
    Shaping written knowledge: The genre and activity of the experimental article in science
  6. 10.1353/lit.2015.0006
     ↗
  7. Bhatia V. K. (2012)
    Insights into academic genres
  8. Bitzer L. F. (1968)
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
  9. 10.1215/03335372-2879838
     ↗
  10. Carter (1992)
    Scholarship as Rhetoric of Display; Or, Why Is Everybody Saying All Those Terri…
    College English
  11. Carter (2021)
    The Construction of Value in Science Research Articles: A Quantitative Study of…
    Written Communication
  12. 10.1353/dia.2015.0003
     ↗
  13. Coleman D. (2011)
    Retooling the humanities: The culture of research in Canadian universities
     ↗
  14. Corrigan (2017)
    Teaching What We Do in Literary Studies
    Pedagogy
  15. 10.13110/criticism.57.2.0191
     ↗
  16. 10.1353/nlh.2015.0003
     ↗
  17. Dobson K. (2011)
    Retooling the humanities: The culture of research in Canadian universities
     ↗
  18. Dowdey D. (1992)
    Constructing rhetorical education
  19. 10.1353/lit.2015.0034
     ↗
  20. 10.1525/ncl.2015.69.4.427
     ↗
  21. FAHNESTOCK et al. (1988)
    The Stases in Scientific and Literary Argument
    Written Communication
  22. Fahnestock J. (1991)
    Textual dynamics of the professions: Historical and contemporary studies of writing in pr…
  23. Freadman A. (2002)
    The rhetoric and ideology of genre
  24. 10.1093/applin/ams050
     ↗
  25. 10.31468/cjsdwr.781
     ↗
  26. 10.31468/cjsdwr.845
     ↗
  27. Google Scholar Metrics. (n.d.). Retrieved June 17, 2019, from https://scholar.google.ca/intl/en/scholar/metri…
  28. 10.31468/cjsdwr.728
     ↗
  29. 10.2307/357971
     ↗
  30. Hyland K. (2000)
    Discipline discourses: Social interactions in academic writing
  31. Jack J. (2019)
    PMLA
  32. 10.3368/cl.56.1.23
     ↗
  33. 10.1353/mfs.2015.0051
     ↗
  34. Linkon S. L. (2011). Literary learning: Teaching the English major. Indiana University Press. https://ebookce…
  35. MacDonald S. P. (1994)
    Professional academic writing in the humanities and social sciences
  36. 10.1080/00335638409383686
     ↗
  37. Miller C. R. (2015)
    Genre studies around the globe
  38. 10.14393/LL63-v31n3a2015-5
     ↗
  39. 10.31468/cjsdwr.843
     ↗
  40. Paré A. (2014)
    Journal of Academic Language and Learning
  41. 10.1086/689662
     ↗
  42. 10.1353/chq.2015.0002
     ↗
  43. Swales J. (1990)
    Genre analysis: English in academic and research settings
  44. 10.1017/CBO9781139524827
     ↗
  45. 10.7330/9781607324430.c009
     ↗
  46. Tardy (2003)
    A Genre System View of the Funding of Academic Research
    Written Communication
  47. 10.1353/esc.2017.0049
     ↗
  48. Walsh (2010)
    The Common Topoi of STEM Discourse: An Apologia and Methodological Proposal, Wi…
    Written Communication
  49. Warren (2006)
    Literary Scholars Processing Poetry and Constructing Arguments
    Written Communication
  50. 10.1353/elh.2015.0042
     ↗
  51. Wilder (2005)
    “The Rhetoric of Literary Criticism” Revisited: Mistaken Critics, Complex Conte…
    Written Communication
  52. Wilder L. (2012)
    Rhetorical strategies and genre conventions in literary studies: Teaching and writing in …
  53. Wolfe J. (2016)
    Digging into literature: Strategies for reading, analysis, and writing
CrossRef global citation count: 4 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related articles

  1. Rhetorica Sep 2019
    Persuading God: Rhetorical Studies of First-Person Psalms by Davida H. Charney ↗
    Stanley E. Porter
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis argument literary studies
  2. Philosophy & Rhetoric Feb 2015
    Deliberative Acts: Democracy, Rhetoric, and Rights ↗
    Belinda Walzer
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis feminist rhetorics argument gender and writing public rhetoric literary studies
  3. Philosophy & Rhetoric Oct 2025
    The Intellectual and Cultural Origins of Chaïm Perelman and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca’s New Rhetoric Project: Commentaries on and Translations of Seven Foundational Articles, 1933–1958 ↗
    Christopher W. Tindale
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis revision argument collaborative writing editorial matter
  4. Rhetoric & Public Affairs Mar 2024
    Literacy in a Long Blues Note: Black Women's Literature and Music in the Late Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries ↗
    Cecilia Cerja
    rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis argument literacy studies race and writing gender and writing public rhetoric literary studies
  5. Pedagogy Jan 2022
    Contributors ↗
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis african american rhetorics decolonial rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy basic writing writing across the curriculum graduate education teacher development argument collaborative writing transfer assessment portfolios writing program administration writing centers peer tutoring technical communication professional writing archival research digital rhetoric social media grammar and mechanics literacy studies race and writing gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric community literacy literary studies editorial matter