Historical Argumentation: Watching Historians and Teaching Youth

Jeffery D. Nokes Brigham Young University ; Susan De La Paz University of Maryland, College Park

Abstract

In this article, we explore the uniqueness of argumentation within the field of history, considering whether historians’ processes in crafting an interpretive argument from inexact evidence might provide insights into processes vital for informed civic engagement and civil dialogue in democratic societies. We discuss the role of argumentation in history, taking both historian (expert) and student (novice) perspectives by considering what historical writing is and how it is produced, taught, and learned. Unlike other research on argumentative historical processes, we examine the role of dispositions that complement skills and enrich collaborations as historians grapple with historical problems together. We examine the role that dispositions and historical thinking skills play as students discuss evidence, plan for argumentative writing, and evaluate their peers’ ideas. We propose that the dispositions and skills involved in historians’ reading, writing, and thinking parallel the critical thinking needed for deliberative and collaborative reasoning about complex social issues. Finally, we explore how instruction and experience with deliberative collaboration within historical problem spaces may prepare students for meaningful civic engagement. We call for increased research on these potential connections.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
2023-04-01
DOI
10.1177/07410883221148679
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation context

Cited by in this index (2)

  1. Written Communication
  2. Written Communication

References (107) · 5 in this index

  1. Alas H. (2021, July 2). Report: Republican-led state legislatures pass dozens of restrictive voting laws in 2…
  2. Assessment of higher order thinking skills
  3. American Press Institute. (2015). How millennials get news: Inside the habits of America’s first digital gene…
  4. Atkinson H., Bardgett S., Budd A., Finn M., Kissane C., Qureshi S., Saha J., Siblon J., Sivasundaram S. (2018…
  5. 10.1037/0033-2909.128.4.612
     ↗
Show all 107 →
  1. 10.1037/a0027476
     ↗
  2. 10.1177/016146811511700202
     ↗
  3. Defining the social studies
  4. 10.3102/0091732X024001061
     ↗
  5. 10.3102/0013189X211017495
     ↗
  6. Teaching and learning history
  7. 10.1086/461623
     ↗
  8. What is history?
  9. Cassidy C. A., Izaguirre A. (2021, January 20). Explainer: Election claims and why it’s clear Biden won. Asso…
  10. 10.1080/00461520.2012.695709
     ↗
  11. 10.1177/1075547019900290
     ↗
  12. 10.1073/pnas.2023301118
     ↗
  13. The idea of history
  14. Corasaniti N., Epstein R. J., Rutenburg J. (2020, November 19). The Times called officials in every state: No…
  15. De La Paz S. (1983). The return of Martin Guerre. Harvard University Press.
  16. 10.1037/0022-0663.97.2.139
     ↗
  17. 10.1016/j.cedpsych.2010.03.001
     ↗
  18. 10.1080/00933104.2014.908754
     ↗
  19. Written Communication
  20. 10.1002/rrq.147
     ↗
  21. 10.4324/9780429423635-12
     ↗
  22. 10.1177/0022219416659444
     ↗
  23. 10.1007/s11145-021-10183-0
     ↗
  24. De Witte M., Driscoll S. (2021, January 6). Stanford scholars react to Capitol Hill takeover. https://news.st…
  25. Best Practices in Writing Instruction
  26. 10.2307/1511296
     ↗
  27. Journal of Judicial Administration
  28. The landscape of history: How historians map the past
  29. 10.1080/07370008.2011.556832
     ↗
  30. They say, I say: The moves that matter in academic writing
  31. Informing writing: The benefits of formative assessment. A Carnegie Corporation Time to A…
  32. Research in the Teaching of English
  33. The theory of communicative action
  34. 10.1080/07370008.2012.716884
     ↗
  35. Handbook of writing research
  36. The political classroom: Evidence and ethics in democratic education
  37. Journal of Contemporary Archival Studies
  38. 10.1207/s15548430jlr3602_2
     ↗
  39. Educational Leadership
  40. Developing citizens: The impact of civic learning opportunities on students’ commitment to civic participation
  41. 10.1111/ropr.12279
     ↗
  42. 10.3102/00028312014001025
     ↗
  43. Lee P. J. (2005). Putting principles into practice: Understanding history. In Donovan M. S., Bransford J. D. …
  44. 10.1207/s1532690xci1404_2
     ↗
  45. 10.2307/1593593
     ↗
  46. 10.1080/00933104.2021.1997844
     ↗
  47. 10.1080/00933104.2017.1416320
     ↗
  48. 10.1007/s11145-020-10117-2
     ↗
  49. 10.1007/s11145-007-9067-9
     ↗
  50. 10.1598/JAAL.52.2.1
     ↗
  51. 10.1080/10508406.2010.481014
     ↗
  52. 10.1080/00405841.2016.1208068
     ↗
  53. Reading, thinking, and writing about history: Teaching argumentative writing to diverse l…
  54. Monte-Sano C., De La Paz S., Felton M., Worland K., Yee L. S., Carey R. L. (2017). Learning to teach discipli…
  55. 10.1177/01614681211058971
     ↗
  56. National Intelligence Council. (2021, March 10). Foreign threats to the 2020 US federal elections (declassifi…
  57. Journal of Writing Research
  58. 10.1002/9781119100812.ch21
     ↗
  59. 10.1037/0022-0663.99.3.492
     ↗
  60. A cultural history of education in the modern age
  61. The History Teacher
  62. Educational psychology
  63. 10.1086/709147
     ↗
  64. Education for democracy: Contexts, curricula, assessments
  65. From Herodotus to H-Net: The story of historiography
  66. 10.1080/07370008.2011.634081
     ↗
  67. 10.1086/518623
     ↗
  68. Demagoguery and democracy
  69. 10.1207/s1532690xci1501_3
     ↗
  70. 10.1080/09500693.2019.1641856
     ↗
  71. 10.1080/00933104.2013.756785
     ↗
  72. Schuessler J. (2020, July 25). Clash of the historians: Paper on Andrew Jackson and Trump causes turmoil. New…
  73. 10.1080/00933104.1994.10505726
     ↗
  74. The handbook of education and human development
  75. The big six: Historical thinking concepts
  76. 10.1093/ahr/rhab197
     ↗
  77. 10.1177/1086296X11424071
     ↗
  78. 10.17763/haer.78.1.v62444321p602101
     ↗
  79. 10.1598/RRQ.31.4.5
     ↗
  80. Stanford History Education Group. (2012). Charting the future of teaching the past. http://sheg.stanford.edu/
  81. 10.1080/00220272.2014.968212
     ↗
  82. 10.1037/edu0000143
     ↗
  83. Stoel G. L., van Drie J. P., van Boxtel C. A. (2009). The principles of teaching based on psychology. BiblioLife.
  84. 10.1525/ohr.2007.34.1.49
     ↗
  85. The guns of August
  86. Notes from China
  87. Practicing history: Selected essays
  88. Journal of Writing Research
  89. 10.1007/s10648-007-9056-1
     ↗
  90. 10.1007/978-3-319-95381-6
     ↗
  91. 10.3102/00028312028003495
     ↗
  92. 10.1207/s15516709cog2203_3
     ↗
  93. Wineburg S., McGrew S. (2019). Lateral reading and the nature of expertise: Reading less and learning more wh…
     ↗
  94. 10.1002/jaal.410
     ↗
  95. 10.1037/edu0000043
     ↗
  96. 10.1037/edu0000740
     ↗
  97. 10.1177/0022219420904343
     ↗
  98. 10.1037/edu0000043
     ↗
  99. 10.1080/00933104.2002.10473201
     ↗
  100. Written Communication
  101. 10.2307/491623
     ↗
  102. A people’s history of the United States: 1492 to present