Beyond Structure: Using the Rational Force Model to Assess Argumentative Writing

Ylva Backman Luleå University of Technology ; Alina Reznitskaya Montclair State University ; Viktor Gardelli Luleå University of Technology ; Ian A. G. Wilkinson The Ohio State University

Abstract

Current approaches used in educational research and practice to evaluate the quality of written arguments often rely on structural analysis. In such assessments, credit is awarded for the presence of structural elements of an argument, such as claims, evidence, and rebuttals. In this article, we discuss limitations of such approaches, including the absence of criteria for evaluating the quality of the argument elements. We then present an alternative framework, based on the Rational Force Model (RFM), which originated from the work of a Nordic philosopher Næss. Using an example of an argumentative essay, we demonstrate the potential of the RFM to improve argument analysis by focusing on the acceptability and relevance of argument elements, two criteria widely considered to be fundamental markers of argument strength. We outline possibilities and challenges with using the RFM in educational contexts and conclude by proposing directions for future research.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
2023-04-01
DOI
10.1177/07410883221148664
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export

Citation context

Cited by in this index (2)

  1. Assessing Writing
  2. Written Communication

References (62) · 4 in this index

  1. 10.1080/00461520.2016.1155458
     ↗
  2. Scientific thinking tools: A base for academic studies
  3. 10.1080/00461520.2020.1786388
     ↗
  4. 10.1002/sce.20402
     ↗
  5. Argumentation analysis: Skills for critical thinking
Show all 62 →
  1. Argumentationsanalys
  2. 10.1016/bs.pmbts.2021.10.002
     ↗
  3. 10.1080/00461520.2017.1341319
     ↗
  4. Personal epistemology and teacher education
  5. Written Communication
  6. Epistemic criteria and reliable processes as indicators of argument quality in science st…
  7. Philosophy & Rhetoric
  8. Written Communication
  9. 10.1037/10903-000
     ↗
  10. 10.1598/RRQ.43.4.5
     ↗
  11. Critical thinking and reasoning
  12. 10.1007/s11422-017-9847-8
     ↗
  13. 10.1002/sce.20012
     ↗
  14. 10.1037/a0014702
     ↗
  15. Argumentasjonsteori, språk og vitenskapsfilosofi
  16. Argumentation analysis: New theory and new applications
  17. 10.1080/00461520.2016.1168741
     ↗
  18. A practical study of argument
  19. 10.4324/9781315795225
     ↗
  20. Truth decay: An initial exploration of the diminishing role of facts and analysis in Amer…
  21. 10.1007/s11422-017-9846-9
     ↗
  22. 10.1002/sce.20395
     ↗
  23. 10.1177/0956797611402512
     ↗
  24. 10.1080/23735082.2015.994254
     ↗
  25. 10.1111/1467-8624.00605
     ↗
  26. 10.1007/s10648-008-9081-8
     ↗
  27. 10.1002/tea.20430
     ↗
  28. 10.1002/sce.21081
     ↗
  29. Supporting grade 5-8 students in constructing explanations in science: The claim, evidenc…
  30. 10.1207/s1532690xci1402_1
     ↗
  31. Communication and argument: Elements of applied semantics
  32. Common core state standards: Appendix A. research supporting key elements of the standards
  33. 10.1598/RRQ.46.3.4
     ↗
  34. 10.1007/s11165-011-9266-x
     ↗
  35. 10.1007/s11145-018-9848-3
     ↗
  36. 10.1126/science.1183944
     ↗
  37. 10.1002/tea.20035
     ↗
  38. 10.5817/SP2019-4-8
     ↗
  39. Partnership for 21st Century Skills. (2012). A Framework for 21st Century Learning. http://www.p21.org/index.php
  40. The end of education: Redefining the value of school
  41. 10.1080/21645515.2020.1780846
     ↗
  42. 10.22329/il.v42i1.7222
     ↗
  43. 10.3102/0034654313487606
     ↗
  44. Comprehension instruction: Research-based best practices
  45. Reznitskaya A., Anderson R. C., McNurlen B., Nguyen-Jahiel K., Archodidou A., Kim S. (2001). Influence of ora…
     ↗
  46. 10.1080/03057640802701952
     ↗
  47. 10.5817/SP2019-4-3
     ↗
  48. 10.1002/sce.20276
     ↗
  49. Curriculum for the compulsory school, preschool class and school-age educare
  50. The uses of argument
  51. 10.3138/9781487574475
     ↗
  52. Argumentation schemes for presumptive reasoning
  53. 10.3138/9781442681859
     ↗
  54. 10.1080/19462166.2013.858183
     ↗
  55. 10.1017/CBO9780511802034
     ↗
  56. Research in the Teaching of English
  57. 10.1002/tea.10008
     ↗