Argumentation Dec 2022 Open Access

Two Types of Refutation in Philosophical Argumentation

Catarina Dutilh Novaes Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam

Abstract

AbstractIn this paper, I highlight the significance of practices of refutation in philosophical inquiry, that is, practices of showing that a claim, person or theory is wrong. I present and contrast two prominent approaches to philosophical refutation: refutation in ancient Greek dialectic (elenchus), in its Socratic variant as described in Plato’s dialogues, and as described in Aristotle’s logical texts; and the practice of providing counterexamples to putative definitions familiar from twentieth century analytic philosophy, focusing on the so-called Gettier problem. Moreover, I discuss Lakatos’ method of proofs and refutations, as it offers insightful observations on the dynamics between arguments, refutations, and counterexamples. Overall, I argue that dialectic, in particular in its Socratic variant, is especially suitable for the philosophical purpose of questioning the obvious, as it invites reflection on one’s own doxastic commitments and on the tensions and inconsistencies within one’s set of beliefs. By contrast, the counterexample-based approach to philosophical refutation can give rise to philosophical theorizing that is overly focused on hairsplitting disputes, thus becoming alienated from the relevant human experiences. Insofar as philosophical inquiry treads the fine line between questioning the obvious while still seeking to say something significant about human experiences, perhaps a certain amount of what Lakatos describes as ‘monster-barring’—a rejection of overly fanciful, artificial putative counterexamples—has its place in philosophical argumentation.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2022-12-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-022-09583-5
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (49) · 1 in this index

  1. Aikin (2011)
    A Defense of War and Sport Metaphors in Argument
    Philosophy & Rhetoric
  2. M Beaney (2017)
    Analytic philosophy: A very short introduction
     ↗
  3. Callard, A. 2019. Is philosophy fight club? The point magazine. https://thepointmag.com/examined-life/is-phil…
  4. B Castelnérac (2009)
    Acts of knowledge: History, philosophy and logic
  5. B Castelnérac (2013)
    Castelnérac, B., and M. Marion. 2013. Antilogic. The Baltic International Yearbook of Cognition, Logic and Co…
    The Baltic International Yearbook of Cognition, Logic and Communication  ↗
Show all 49 →
  1. Chappell, S.-G. 2019. Plato on knowledge in the theaetetus. In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://p…
  2. RM Chisholm (1977)
    Theory of knowledge
  3. DH Cohen (1995)
    Cohen, D.H. 1995. Argument is War...and War is Hell: Philosophy, education, and metaphors for argumentation. …
    Informal Logic  ↗
  4. M Duncombe (2016)
    Duncombe, M., and C. DutilhNovaes. 2016. Dialectic and logic in Aristotle and his tradition. History and Phil…
    History and Philosophy of Logic  ↗
  5. J Dutant (2015)
    Dutant, J. 2015. The legend of the justified true belief analysis. Philosophical Perspectives 29(1): 95–145. …
    Philosophical Perspectives  ↗
  6. C Dutilh Novaes (2016)
    Dutilh Novaes, C. 2016. Reductio ad absurdum from a dialogical perspective. Philosophical Studies 173: 2605–2628.
    Philosophical Studies  ↗
  7. Dutilh Novaes, C. 2019. The human factor: Doing philosophy in a messy world by asking inconvenient questions.…
  8. C Dutilh Novaes (2020)
    Polarisation, arrogance, and dogmatism: Philosophical perspectives
  9. C Dutilh Novaes (2020)
    The dialogical roots of deduction
     ↗
  10. C Dutilh Novaes (2021)
    Dutilh Novaes, C. 2021. Who’s afraid of adversariality? Conflict and cooperation in argumentation. Topoi 40(5…
    Topoi  ↗
  11. C Dutilh Novaes (2017)
    Innovations in the history of analytical philosophy
     ↗
  12. JL Fink (2012)
    The development of dialectic from Plato to Aristotle
     ↗
  13. TS Gendler (2005)
    Gendler, T.S., and J. Hawthorne. 2005. The real guide to fake barns: A catalogue of gifts for your epistemic …
    Philosophical Studies  ↗
  14. EL Gettier (1963)
    Gettier, E.L. 1963. Is justified true belief knowledge? Analysis 23(6): 121–123. https://doi.org/10.1093/anal…
    Analysis  ↗
  15. AI Goldman (1976)
    Goldman, A.I. 1976. Discrimination and perceptual knowledge. The Journal of Philosophy 73(20): 771. https://d…
    The Journal of Philosophy  ↗
  16. Hundleby, C. 2021. Feminist perspectives on argumentation. In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://pl…
  17. Ichikawa, J. J., & M. Steup. 2018. The analysis of knowledge. In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https:/…
  18. T Irani (2017)
    Plato on the value of philosophy
     ↗
  19. IJ Kidd (2020)
    Polarisation, arrogance, and dogmatism: Philosophical perspectives
     ↗
  20. Kirk, A. 2020. Euler’s polyhedron formula. Plus Magazine. https://plus.maths.org/content/eulers-polyhedron-formula.
  21. T Koetsier (1991)
    Lakatos’ philosophy of mathematics: A historical approach
  22. I Lakatos (1976)
    Proofs and refutations: The logic of mathematical discovery
     ↗
  23. B Larvor (2001)
    Larvor, B. 2001. What is dialectical philosophy of mathematics? Philosophia Mathematica 9: 212–229.
    Philosophia Mathematica  ↗
  24. JH Lesher (2002)
    Does Socrates have a method?
  25. Leslie, S.-J., & A. Lerner. 2016. Generic generalizations. In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://pl…
  26. G Matthews (2009)
    Matthews, G. 2009. Whatever became of the socratic elenchus? Philosophical analysis in Plato. Philosophy Comp…
    Philosophy Compass  ↗
  27. JS Mill (1999)
    On liberty
  28. J Moss (2007)
    Moss, J. 2007. The doctor and the pastry chef; pleasure and persuasion in Plato’s Gorgias. Ancient Philosophy…
    Ancient Philosophy  ↗
  29. J Moulton (1983)
    Discovering reality
  30. Musgrave, A., & C. Pigden. 2016. Imre Lakatos. In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://plato.stanford…
  31. L Nauta (2009)
    In Defense of common sense: Lorenzo Valla’s humanist critique of scholastic philosophy
  32. A Nehamas (1990)
    Nehamas, A. 1990. Eristic, antilogic, sophistic, dialectic: Plato’s demarcation of philosophy from sophistry.…
    History of Philosophy Quarterly
  33. KR Popper (1989)
    Conjectures and refutations: The growth of scientific knowledge
  34. D Pritchard (2005)
    Epistemic luck
     ↗
  35. D Sedley (2004)
    The midwife of platonism: Text and subtext in Plato’s theaetetus
     ↗
  36. R Smith (1997)
    Aristotle’s topics—Books I and VIII
  37. Strevens, M. 2021. The knowledge machine: How irrationality created modern science. Penguin Books.
  38. Tanswell, F. S. 2017. Proof, rigour & informality: A virtue account of mathematical knowledge. PhD Dissertati…
  39. FS Tanswell (2018)
    Tanswell, F.S. 2018. Conceptual engineering for mathematical concepts. Inquiry 61: 881–913.
    Inquiry  ↗
  40. J Turri (2016)
    A companion to experimental philosophy
     ↗
  41. Weinberg, J. M. 2016. Intuitions. In Oxford Handbook of Philosophical Methodology, eds. H. Cappelen, T. S. Ge…
     ↗
  42. T Williamson (2002)
    Knowledge and its limits
     ↗
  43. T Williamson (2005)
    Williamson, T. 2005. Armchair philosophy, metaphysical modality and counterfactual thinking. Proceedings of t…
    Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society (hardback)  ↗
  44. L Zagzebski (1994)
    Zagzebski, L. 1994. The inescapability of Gettier problems. The Philosophical Quarterly 44(174): 65. https://…
    The Philosophical Quarterly  ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 5 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related articles

  1. Res Rhetorica Oct 2026
    Inclusive leadership as a discursive-rhetorical practice: A conceptual framework of discourse, identity and power ↗
    Zita Komár
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument
  2. Poroi Feb 2026
    Using Stasis Theory as a Heuristic for Examining Epistemological Dilemmas in a Post-Truth Landscape ↗
    Bruce Bowles
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument
  3. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly Apr 2025
    Gendered Persuasive Language in Business Negotiations: A Case Study of Shark Tank US ↗
    Nguyen Thi Hoang Bau; Thai Le Thuy Trang
    classical rhetoric composition theory argument qualitative research gender and writing
  4. Rhetoric & Public Affairs Sep 2024
    Populist Rhetorics Case Studies and a Minimalist Definition ↗
    Arthur E. Walzer
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument digital rhetoric social media disability studies public rhetoric editorial matter
  5. Rhetoric & Public Affairs Mar 2024
    Disorder in the Court: Morality, Myth, and the Insanity Defense ↗
    Jaclyn Bruner
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism argument