Argumentation Mar 2026 Open Access

Is a Contradiction Between Arguments Less Likely to be Noticed When They are Implicit? An Experimental Case Study

Edoardo Lombardi Vallauri Roma Tre University

Abstract

The paper investigates whether contradictory arguments are less likely to be noticed when they are expressed implicitly rather than explicitly. It builds on the fact that—in natural language productions—contradictions are often not logical but rather—lato sensu—pragmatic in nature. The study presents an experiment using ecological and slightly modified material. In a Facebook post, Italian journalist Selvaggia Lucarelli conveyed two contradictory arguments through implicatures, presuppositions and vague expressions. This text was presented to experimental subjects: half read the original version, while the other half read a version in which the implicit content had been made explicit. Their responses to specific questions indicate that the contradiction is more easily noticed when it occurs between explicit assertions rather than between arguments that must be at least partially inferred. A strong effect is observed in relation to age and education differences among the groups. These results may provide experimental insight into the conditions under which argumentation flawed by contradictions may still achieve its intended effect, as if the contradiction were not present.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2026-03-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-025-09686-9
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation context

Cited by in this index (1)

  1. Schumann et al. (2026)
    Benefits, Diversity, and Prospects of Experimental Methods in Argumentation
    Argumentation

References (63) · 2 in this index

  1. Sarah Bigi (2012)
    Bigi, Sarah, and Sara Greco Morasso. 2012. Keywords, frames and the reconstruction of material starting point…
    Journal of Pragmatics  ↗
  2. Bonevac, Daniel. 2003. Deduction: Introductory Symbolic Logic. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
  3. N Bonini (1999)
    Bonini, N., D. Osherson, R. Viale, and T. Williamson. 1999. On the psychology of vague predicates. Mind & Lan…
    Mind & Language  ↗
  4. Marc Brysbaert (2019)
    Brysbaert, Marc. 2019. How many participants do we have to include in properly powered experiments? A tutoria…
    Journal of Cognition  ↗
  5. Morten Christiansen (2016)
    Christiansen, Morten, and Nick Chater. 2016. The now-or-never bottleneck: A fundamental constraint on languag…
    Behavioral and Brain Sciences  ↗
Show all 63 →
  1. De Marneffe, Marie-Catherine. 2012. What’s that supposed to mean? Modeling the pragmatic meaning of utterance…
  2. Louis De Saussure (2013)
    De Saussure, Louis. 2013. Background relevance. Journal of Pragmatics 59: 178–189.
    Journal of Pragmatics  ↗
  3. Valentina Dragos (2017)
    Dragos, Valentina. 2017. Detection of contradictions by relation matching and uncertainty assessment. Procedi…
    Procedia Computer Science  ↗
  4. Oswald Ducrot (1972)
    Dire et ne pas dire
  5. Erickson, Thomas D., and Mark E. Mattson. 1981. From words to meanings: A semantic illusion. Journal of Verba…
     ↗
  6. Jane Evison (2007)
    Vague language explored
     ↗
  7. Ferreira, Ademar. 2008. On the role of pragmatics, rhetoric and dialectic in scientific controversies. In Con…
     ↗
  8. Gerd Gigerenzer (2008)
    Gigerenzer, Gerd. 2008. Why heuristics work. Perspectives on Psychological Science 3 (1): 20–29.
    Perspectives on Psychological Science  ↗
  9. Talmy Givón (1982)
    Givón, Talmy. 1982. Evidentiality and epistemic space. Studies in Language 61: 23–49.
    Studies in Language  ↗
  10. Sara Greco Morasso (2012)
    Greco Morasso, Sara. 2012. Contextual frames and their argumentative implications: A case study in media argu…
    Discourse Studies  ↗
  11. JeanBlaise Grize (1995)
    Grize, Jean Blaise, and Gilberte Piéraut-Le Bonniec. 1995. The uses of contradiction in argumentative discour…
    Journal of Pragmatics  ↗
  12. CharlesLeonard Hamblin (1970)
    Fallacies
  13. Harabagiu, Sanda, Andrew Hickl and Finley Lacatusu. 2006. Negation, Contrast and Contradiction in Text Proces…
  14. Peter A Hornby (1974)
    Hornby, Peter A. 1974. Surface structure and presupposition. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1…
    Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior  ↗
  15. David E Irwin (1982)
    Irwin, David E., J. Kathryn Bock, and Keith E. Stanovich. 1982. Effects of information structure cues on visu…
    Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior  ↗
  16. Catherine Kerbrat-Orecchioni (1986)
    L’Implicite
  17. Krebs, John R., and Richard Dawkins. 1984. Animal Signals: Mind-reading and Manipulation. In Behavioural Ecol…
  18. George Lakoff (1972)
    Lakoff, George. 1972. A study in meaning criteria and the logic of fuzzy concepts. Chicago Linguistic Society…
    Chicago Linguistic Society Papers
  19. J Langford (1979)
    Langford, J., and V. M. Holmes. 1979. Syntactic presupposition in sentence comprehension. Cognition 7:363–383.
    Cognition  ↗
  20. Lessl, Thomas M. 2008. Scientific demarcation and metascience. The national academy of sciences on greenhouse…
     ↗
  21. Elizabeth F Loftus (1975)
    Loftus, Elizabeth F. 1975. Leading questions and the eyewitness report. Cognitive Psychology 7:550–572.
    Cognitive Psychology  ↗
  22. Lombardi Vallauri, Edoardo. 1995. Tratti linguistici della persuasione in pubblicità. Lingua Nostra 2 (3): 41–51.
  23. Lombardi Vallauri, Edoardo. 2009. La struttura informativa. Forma e funzione negli enunciati linguistici. Rom…
  24. Lombardi Vallauri, Edoardo and Viviana Masia. 2014. Implicitness Impact: Measuring texts. Journal of Pragmati…
     ↗
  25. Lombardi Vallauri, Edoardo. 2016. The “exaptation” of linguistic implicit strategies. SpringerPlus 5(1): 1–24.
     ↗
  26. Lombardi Vallauri, Edoardo. 2019. La lingua disonesta. Bologna, il Mulino.
  27. Lombardi Vallauri, Edoardo. (2021) Manipulative Shallow Processing Induced by Presuppositions and Topics: The…
     ↗
  28. Macagno (2024)
    Presuppositional Fallacies
    Argumentation
  29. Macagno, Fabrizio, and Douglas Walton. 2013. Implicatures as forms of argument. In Perspectives on pragmatics…
     ↗
  30. Giorgia Mannaioli (2024)
    Mannaioli, Giorgia, Alessandro Ansani, Claudia Coppola, and Edoardo Lombardi Vallauri. 2024. Vagueness as an …
    Cognitive Processing  ↗
  31. Mannaioli, Giorgia. 2025. Vagueness as an Implicitating Persuasive Strategy. John Benjamins.
     ↗
  32. Hugo Mercier (2011)
    Mercier, Hugo. 2011. On the universality of argumentative reasoning. Journal of Cognition and Culture 11:85–113.
    Journal of Cognition and Culture  ↗
  33. Mercier, Hugo. 2009. La Théorie Argumentative du Raisonnement. Ph.D. Thesis in Social Sciences, E.H.E.S.S, Paris.
  34. Chiara Mercuri (2023)
    Mercuri, Chiara. 2023. Characterization frames constructing endoxa in activists’ discourse about the public c…
    Topoi  ↗
  35. O’Keeffe, A., and W. Cheng. 2015. Vague language. In Corpus Pragmatics: A Handbook, ed. Karin Aijmer and Cris…
  36. Steve Oswald (2023)
    Oswald, Steve. 2023. Pragmatics for argumentation. Journal of Pragmatics 203:144–156.
    Journal of Pragmatics  ↗
  37. Oswald, Steve, Didier Maillat, and Louis de Saussure. 2016. Deceptive and uncooperative verbal communication.…
     ↗
  38. Oswald, Steve. 2018. Pragmatic Inference and Argumentative Inference. In Argumentation and Inference: Proceed…
  39. Anne Reboul (2011)
    Reboul, Anne. 2011. A relevance-theoretic account of the evolution of implicit communication. Studies in Prag…
    Studies in Pragmatics
  40. Anne Reboul (2017)
    Cognition and communication in the evolution of language
     ↗
  41. Regner, Anna Carolina. 2008. Charles Darwin versus George Mivart. The role of polemics in science. In Controv…
     ↗
  42. Rigotti, Eddo. 1988. Significato e senso. In AA.VV, Ricerche di semantica testuale. Brescia: La Scuola, 71–120.
  43. Eddo Rigotti (2019)
    Inference in argumentation: a topics-based approach to argument schemes
     ↗
  44. Bertrand Russell (1923)
    Russell, Bertrand. 1923. Vagueness. The Australasian Journal of Psychology and Philosophy 1 (2): 84–92.
    The Australasian Journal of Psychology and Philosophy  ↗
  45. Marina Sbisà (2021)
    Sbisà, Marina. 2021. Presupposition and implicature: Varieties of implicit meaning in explicitation practices…
    Journal of Pragmatics  ↗
  46. Sbisà, Marina. 2007. Detto non detto. Le forme della comunicazione implicita. Roma-Bari: Laterza.
  47. Florian Schwarz (2016)
    Schwarz, Florian. 2016. False but slow: Evaluating statements with non-referring definites. Journal of Semant…
    Journal of Semantics
  48. Schwarz, Florian. 2015. Presuppositions vs. Asserted Content in Online Processing. In Experimental Perspectiv…
     ↗
  49. D Shmueli (2008)
    Shmueli, D. 2008. Framing in geographical analysis of environmental conflicts: Theory, methodology and three …
    Geoforum  ↗
  50. Dan Sperber (1995)
    and Deirdre Wilson
  51. Dan Sperber (2010)
    Sperber, Dan, Fabrice Clément, Christophe Heintz, Olivier Mascaro, Hugo Mercier, Gloria Origgi, and Deirdre W…
    Mind & Language  ↗
  52. Robert Stalnaker (2002)
    Stalnaker, Robert. 2002. Common ground. Linguistics and Philosophy 25:701–721.
    Linguistics and Philosophy  ↗
  53. Strawson, Peter F. 1964. Identifying Reference and Truth-Values. Theoria 302: 96–118. Rep. in Idem. 1971. Log…
     ↗
  54. StephenE. Toulmin (1958)
    The uses of argument
  55. Amos Tversky (1974)
    Tversky, Amos, and Daniel Kahneman. 1974. Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science 185 (415…
    Science  ↗
  56. Eemeren et al. (2006)
    Strategic Maneuvering: A Synthetic Recapitulation
    Argumentation
  57. van Eemeren, Frans H., and Bart Garssen, eds. 2008. Controversy and confrontation. John Benjamins Publishing …
     ↗
  58. van Eemeren, Frans H. 2010. Strategic Maneuvering in Argumentative Discourse. Extending the Pragma-Dialectica…
     ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related articles

  1. Technical Communication Quarterly Jan 2025
    Constructed Ethos and Kairotic Responses in Communicating About the COVID-19 Pandemic to the Chinese Public: A Rhetorical Analysis of Dr. Wenhong Zhang’s Posts on WeChat ↗
    Jianfen Chen
    rhetorical criticism argument qualitative research social media
  2. Philosophy & Rhetoric Sep 2024
    Where’s the Rhetoric? Imagining a Unified Field ↗
    Joshua Hanan
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism composition theory genre theory discourse analysis cultural rhetorics argument qualitative research quantitative research digital rhetoric social media grammar and mechanics gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric affect and writing body and rhetoric editorial matter
  3. Rhetoric & Public Affairs Mar 2024
    Demagogue for President: The Rhetorical Genius of Donald Trump ↗
    Tyler Easterbrook
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis writing pedagogy argument qualitative research social media public rhetoric editorial matter
  4. Philosophy & Rhetoric Dec 2023
    Limit Formations: Violence, Philosophy, Rhetoric ↗
    Omedi Ochieng
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis voice and style argument qualitative research social media race and writing gender and writing editorial matter
  5. Rhetoric of Health and Medicine Jun 2022
    Bridging Experience and Expertise: A Case Study of COVID-19 Vaccine Trial Participation and Social Media Vaccine Communication ↗
    Kari Campeau
    argument qualitative research social media